Forums > Windsurfing Gear Reviews

Duotone Mega Slim vs Chinook RDG

Reply
Created by philn > 9 months ago, 9 Jan 2022
philn
725 posts
9 Jan 2022 1:26AM
Thumbs Up

I'm selling my Chinook carbon RDG because it's floppier than a wet noodle. But I love the tiny grip size. I also have the Goya super skinny 150-200 and that boom is significantly stiffer than the chinook RDG, but it's also a slightly larger diameter grip size. Is the Duotone Mega Slim any stiffer than the Chinook.

Mark _australia
WA, 22089 posts
13 Jan 2022 10:15PM
Thumbs Up

Skinny = bendy

Not a fan. The moderate increase in comfort is not worth the massive bendy noodle effect for me.

LeeD
3939 posts
14 Jan 2022 1:37AM
Thumbs Up

Little guy with diminishing skills. 73 kg., 73 years old.
Love bendy alu booms. All last more than a handful of years. Think 15 year old standard alu Chinook half extended is too stiff.
Found my 30 year old, used close to 200 days, old Euro boom in Puerto Rico, used it 12 days there, and was thinking of bringing it back to San Francisco with me. American said..."no".
I sailed it all in small surf and onshore wind with 5.5. Wind 10-20.

LeeD
3939 posts
14 Jan 2022 1:54AM
Thumbs Up

Oh....always had carbon booms since 1993.
For racing and speed, they were good.
For waves, they place more stress on masts, and I preferred sdm for float.
Past 20 years no comps, only rec sailing. I like using the smallest sail for anyone my weight, so don't need stiff booms.
For windsurfing in typical 14-21 knot breeze, 5-6 is my choice.
I can hold my slalom sails in 7.8 sizing easily at that windspeed. A 7.0 is my choice.
I typically sail with guys who use 1-2 meters bigger sails and full on slalom boards. Most can jibe 95%.
I am always top 90% for speed and planing thru jibes out of 30 rec shortboarders.

Al1
49 posts
14 Jan 2022 10:39AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Mark _australia said..
Skinny = bendy

Not a fan. The moderate increase in comfort is not worth the massive bendy noodle effect for me.


Try a highend one like the Duotone or Pryde, pricey but super stiff. The Chinook RDG is notorious for not being rigid enough, I have the Duotone mega slim and it's just night and day. Now I'm not a fan of the shape of the curve (I prefer the rounder designs like the NP) but that's another thing

Mark _australia
WA, 22089 posts
14 Jan 2022 12:19PM
Thumbs Up

They still bend more, regardless of how premium they are....... its a fact of life that for same weight a wider tube bends less.

As to the strength - I dunno if skinner is stronger but I know the only carbon booms I've broken have been the skinnies, I'm back up to 28 or 29mm again with no issues - Simmer Blackline (5y/o ish) and similar age North Platinum.

JakeNN
351 posts
14 Jan 2022 10:15PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Mark _australia said..
Skinny = bendy

Not a fan. The moderate increase in comfort is not worth the massive bendy noodle effect for me.


Unfortunately not everyone is the same and some people can't sail more than 10 mins with standard diameter booms.

Which would you choose:
Standard diameter boom = 10 mins on water, then rest time on beach due to forearm pump
RDM boom = 3 hours on water

JakeNN
351 posts
14 Jan 2022 10:17PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
philn said..
Is the Duotone Mega Slim any stiffer than the Chinook.


Suggest you also consider booms with a v-grip.

I tested a few booms and a v-grip with an extra 1mm at say 25mm ... result is that a 25mm v-grip is more comfortable than a 24mm normal diameter.

AL360 is the way to go.

Mark _australia
WA, 22089 posts
14 Jan 2022 11:36PM
Thumbs Up

Might need to look at your technique Jake

LeeD
3939 posts
15 Jan 2022 12:23AM
Thumbs Up

Those "v" booms are easier to hold sans harness.
But, for some peeps like me, they really point load and cause early callous to blister to ripped hands.
I got rid of my last Fleetwood carbon oval grip 10 years ago.
Prefer round and slightly flexy at old age.

Nerdburger
NSW, 286 posts
15 Jan 2022 6:47AM
Thumbs Up

I've had,, severne, chinook rdg carbon booms.
My 2 cents as a larger wave sailor, 90/95 kg, using big sails 5.5/5.8 in light and gusty conditions and powerful waves.
Ive found them stiff, great quality, the chinook has an overly complicated grip all the lettering, didn't last, re gripped after 2 season, still going strong. The rear end could be wider for bagging out sails a bit for float and ride.
The carbon is stiff, light, and great quality, made in USA by chinook. Not a China by third party and re branded.The severne grip is excellent from new. The clamp head needed re shimming, I think they all do, sand between carbon and plastic.
Ive seen the duotone top end one and it looks awesome, it's light, slim and expensive.
Goya rdg also excellent, I believe they are a generic boom, banded for Goya but could be wrong.
Another to consider if you don't want super slim, is streamline carbon. Made in house, alloy clamp. Super strong and stiff. No loop and go on boom end though.

philn
725 posts
25 Jan 2022 5:24AM
Thumbs Up

I decided to get the Duotone Mega Slim 150-200. The workmanship and quality are streaks ahead of the carbon Chinook RDG, and it is significantly stiffer. Almost as stiff as the Goya Super Skinny 150-200, but with a noticeably skinnier grip. So far I've used it with my 5.5 (26 cm extension) and I didn't notice any flex while sailing. Using the same amount of extension on the carbon Chinook RDG and every gust or pump the boom would flex like crazy. I really like the Duotone boom, but the Goya Super Skinny is also a superb boom, and considering that it is US$180 cheaper than the Duotone, it wins the value for money choice.

Manuel7
1229 posts
25 Jan 2022 11:35PM
Thumbs Up

Head flex can increase the soft feel.
Apparently Maui sails head is "better".
No complaint about severne metal alu, heavy but stiff and lasts.
Are you sure flex comes from tubes?
It can be measured by using different levels of extension stepping on one arm and pulling on the other.

philn
725 posts
26 Jan 2022 6:18AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Manuel7 said..
Are you sure flex comes from tubes?


Does it matter where it comes from if some booms are flexy and others are not? Just don't buy the flexy booms.

BSN101
WA, 2244 posts
26 Jan 2022 9:01AM
Thumbs Up

NP have a new skinny boom.

Manuel7
1229 posts
26 Jan 2022 11:17AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
philn said..

Manuel7 said..
Are you sure flex comes from tubes?



Does it matter where it comes from if some booms are flexy and others are not? Just don't buy the flexy booms.


Parts can be swapped.. Some heads soften (or break) faster while the rest is still tight.

Mark _australia
WA, 22089 posts
27 Jan 2022 9:07PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
philn said..


Manuel7 said..
Are you sure flex comes from tubes?




Does it matter where it comes from if some booms are flexy and others are not? Just don't buy the flexy booms.



It does matter

For the same weight, a wider tube is stiffer. Engineering fact.

So the flip side of your statement is why bother with a nice stiff back end and head, and good tolerances, if the trendy 24mm tube bends lots...?

LeeD
3939 posts
28 Jan 2022 12:39AM
Thumbs Up

Marketing?
And ONE Head for all booms?

Snapfigure
117 posts
28 Jan 2022 3:31AM
Thumbs Up

duotone slim flexes a lot and front part and clips start to get loose and floppy in just in few months normal diameter is stiffer but the same for clips and front part sold it in just 4 months the same for Goya Severne better quality but not that stiff
Many of modern carbon booms are made in the same factory Got the new NP piece of art reduced diameter still very very stiff 4 months now not floppy It S unbelievable boom best ever made like it much more than any normal diameter But I am not sure if the kafros custom made booms 25 mm is even better You cant believe this one piece direct feeling unless you ride it snot even 0.00001 % floppy and just by choosing the regular stiffness the stiffer are for 100+ Kg I can send videos showing the stiffness of each boom

LeeD
3939 posts
28 Jan 2022 4:07AM
Thumbs Up

Floppy saves sdm masts, not important with rdms.

Gwarn
202 posts
1 Mar 2022 10:08PM
Thumbs Up

For me the duotone was ok the grip lasted longer then any other boom I've owned.

Got catapulted and the head gave.
The clips cracked early on butt never failed.

My recommendation is if you own one of these booms order spare parts now and have them in the van.
I felt I got my money's worth out of it.

Got back on an old streamline boom even when the duotone was new it's was not even close to being as stiff as a streamlined.







Imax1
QLD, 4524 posts
2 Mar 2022 11:08AM
Thumbs Up

+1 for v grip . I simply v grip round thick booms before even using them . Simply stick a 12mm wide , 6mm thick strip of MD eva where your hands go . Don't need heaps, just a foot either side of harness line area. Hit it smooth with a sanding block into a nice rounded lump . With good contact cement doesn't come off .Spongy and kinda soft , is a pleasure to use and makes a huge difference . Finger tips sit under the lump and the hand won't spin off . Only use a fraction of effort to hang on .

LeeD
3939 posts
2 Mar 2022 9:23AM
Thumbs Up

Innovation! Good stuff!

Al1
49 posts
22 Mar 2022 10:00AM
Thumbs Up

I'm eyeing the new Neil Pryde carbon slim, I like the curve a lot more than the Duotone, which I find retarded

jn1
2454 posts
22 Mar 2022 7:17PM
Thumbs Up

I brought a Chinook 150-200 RDG a few years ago. And yeah, you're right. I did a test just then. My old 2/11 140-180 carbon boom has much less flex. Is the RDG better than an aluminium boom in the same size ?. I don't remember now. It's been 10 years since I owned an AL boom. If it's similar, then that's pretty bad. The skinny grip of the RDG makes my hands go numb. I prefer the bigger diameter grip.

When you all talk about vgrip above, is this the Aeron vgrip booms ?. What are people's thoughts on the latest Aeron carbon wave booms ?. They used to be a very good brand IMO. It's been a long time since I owned one.

JakeNN
351 posts
22 Mar 2022 9:57PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Al1 said..
I'm eyeing the new Neil Pryde carbon slim, I like the curve a lot more than the Duotone, which I find retarded


IMHO the NP have the best quality feel ... but good luck with pricing and availability.

JakeNN
351 posts
22 Mar 2022 10:00PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
jn1 said..
The skinny grip of the RDG makes my hands go numb. I prefer the bigger diameter grip.

When you all talk about vgrip above, is this the Aeron vgrip booms ?. What are people's thoughts on the latest Aeron carbon wave booms ?. They used to be a very good brand IMO. It's been a long time since I owned one.


Wow .. I wish I had this problem! The thinner the better for me. Forearm pump with normal diameter booms for me :(

Why would you consider a vgrip based on your preference for bigger diameter grips? The vgrip effectively gives you a smaller diameter feel as the V hooks into your fingers, just like a skinny boom.

jn1
2454 posts
23 Mar 2022 10:23AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
JakeNN said..


jn1 said..
The skinny grip of the RDG makes my hands go numb. I prefer the bigger diameter grip.

When you all talk about vgrip above, is this the Aeron vgrip booms ?. What are people's thoughts on the latest Aeron carbon wave booms ?. They used to be a very good brand IMO. It's been a long time since I owned one.




Wow .. I wish I had this problem! The thinner the better for me. Forearm pump with normal diameter booms for me :(

Why would you consider a vgrip based on your preference for bigger diameter grips? The vgrip effectively gives you a smaller diameter feel as the V hooks into your fingers, just like a skinny boom.



I guess my question is: what does the cross section of a vgrip look like ?.

Ps/ numb hands normally occur after 2hr sailing. It's not a big deal for me.

Manuel7
1229 posts
24 Mar 2022 1:28AM
Thumbs Up

I have two simmer carbon booms, 2014-2018(?) One has 29-30mm diameter including grip, the other more like 30-31mm. 29mm is perfect, 30+ feels a bit thick.

Was surprised when measured that there wasn't even more difference because on the water, makes a bit difference.

I remember sanding it down some, depending on grip, can make a big difference.

WindFlyer
156 posts
19 Apr 2022 9:22AM
Thumbs Up

yes, i do realise this is ultimately a matter of personal preference, but i'm not a huge fan of the super-skinny grip booms (~25mm). i'm quite happy (with smallish hands) with 27-28mm grips.

that said, i've had a chance to test four super slim booms (by Chinook, Duotone, Goya, and Severne). my impression is that the Severne Enigma (140 or 150, pick your choice) is the stiffest of the lot.

aeroegnr
1478 posts
19 Apr 2022 9:45AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
WindFlyer said..
yes, i do realise this is ultimately a matter of personal preference, but i'm not a huge fan of the super-skinny grip booms (~25mm). i'm quite happy (with smallish hands) with 27-28mm grips.

that said, i've had a chance to test four super slim booms (by Chinook, Duotone, Goya, and Severne). my impression is that the Severne Enigma (140 or 150, pick your choice) is the stiffest of the lot.


Being ignorant, I was skeptical about carbon booms that small but I recently got the Enigma 140 and it feels so much smaller, more comfortable, stiffer, and sturdy than my normal freeride aluminum booms (160-210ish). The large IQFoil boom is stiff as hell but also huge in diameter in comparison.



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Windsurfing Gear Reviews


"Duotone Mega Slim vs Chinook RDG" started by philn